McHenry County Audubon Society

Tree Comparisons Between Swink & Wilhelm C Values and Wildlife Food Values for the Chicago Region

Membership Brochure
Calendar
Newsletters
Christmas & Spring Counts
Injured Wildlife
Links
Checklists
McHenry County Birds
Wildlife Resources
Photo Gallery

Tree Comparisons Between Swink & Wilhelm C Values and Wildlife Food Values for the Chicago Region

Most of us have had the experience of being in a very high quality natural area with many rare and conservative plant species, but not finding many animal species.  The current conservation theory is that if the plant communities are improved, the animals will follow.  This may not always be true.  This handout is designed to provide additional input for planting and restoration so that animal food sources may be taken into account in addition to purely focusing on plant quality ratings.

Tree/Bush Species

Swink & Wilhelm #

Wildlife Value  for Food & Shelter

Box Elder

0

8      (V, s, w, sm, b, I, bud)

Black Maple

5

9      (V, s, u, lm, sm, b, I, bud)

Red Maple

7

10    (V, s, w, sm, b, I, bud, h, n)

Silver Maple

0

9      (V, s, w, wa, sm, b, I, bud)

Sugar Maple

3

9      (V, s, u, sm, b, I, b, n)

Ohio Buckeye

3

2      (L, sm, I)

Tree of Heaven

Alien

0      (L)

Black Alder

Alien

2.5   (M, s, u)

American Shadbush

9

3      (O, s, sm)

Smooth Shadbush

8

3      (O, s, sm)

Paw Paw

9

1      (L, sm)

Yellow Birch

10

8      (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud)

River Birch

7

9      (V, s, u, w, sm, b, bud, h)

Paper Birch

10

6      (O, s, u, sm, I, bud)

Blue Beech

8

2      (L, s, w)

Bitternut Hickory

7

2.5   (M, s, sm)

Pignut Hickory

5

5.5   (M, s, sm, I, h, n)

Shagbark Hickory

5

3.5   (M, s, sm, I)

Mockernut Hickory

10

3.5   (M, s, sm, I)

Catalpa

Alien

0      (L)

Hackberry

3

7      (V, s, sm, I, h, n)

American Bittersweet (climbing)

4

1      (L, h)

Redbud

3

0      (L)

Hazelnut

5

3.5   (M, u, sm, bud)

Pagoda Dogwood

9

9      (V, u, s, w, lm, sm, b, bud)

Rough-leaved Dogwood

2

6      (O, s, u, b, h, n)

Gray Dogwood

1

6      (O, s, u, b, h, n)

Red Osier Dogwood

6

6      (O, s, u, b, h, n)

Round-leaved Dogwood

10

4      (O, s, u, b)

Cock-spur Thorn

2

6.5   (M, s, u, sm, b, lm, I)

Red Haw

2

7.5   (M, s, u, sm, b, lm, I, bud)

Pruinose Haw

2

6.5   (M, s, u, sm, b, lm, I)

Beech

5

5.5   (M, sm, I, bud, h, n)

White Ash

5

2      (L, h, n)

Black Ash

10

3      (L, s, sm, I)

Red Ash

5

4      (L. s, sm, I)

Green Ash

1

6      (L, s, sm, b, I, h, n)

Blue Ash

8

3      (L, s, sm, I)

Honey Locust

2

5      (L, s, sm, I, h, n)

Kentucky Coffee Tree

8

0      (L)

Witch Hazel

8

4      (L, s, sm, b, h)

Butternut/White Walnut

8

1      (L, sm)

Black Walnut

5

1      (L, sm)

Common Juniper

10

5      (O, s, b, h, n)

Red Cedar

2

9      (V, s, u, sm, b, bud, h, n)

European Larch

Alien

2      (L, s, u)

Tamarack

10

3.5   (M, s, sm, I)

Osage Orange

Alien

0      (L)

Prairie Crab Apple

4

5.5   (M, u, sm, lm, h, n)

Iowa Crab

3

7.5   (M, s, u, sm, lm, I, h ,n)

White Mulberry

Alien

2      (L, s, u)

Red Mulberry

10

6      (O, sm, lm, u, s, I)

Hop Hornbeam/Musclewood

5

4      (L, s, sm, b, h)

Jack Pine

9

8      (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud)

White Pine

9

9      (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud, h)

Scotch Pine

Alien

5      (V, s, u, h)

Sycamore

9

2.5   (M, h, n)

Tree/Bush Species

Swink & Wilhelm #

Wildlife Value for Food & Shelter

White Poplar

Alien

8.5     (M, s, u, b, sm, I, bud, h, n)

Cottonwood

3

10      (O, s, u, sm, w, b, I, bud, h, n)

Big-tooth Aspen

6

7        (O, s, u, b, sm, I, bud)

Quacking Aspen

4

4.5     (M, u, sm, I, bud)

Wild Plum

5

4        (L, s, u, sm, h)

Black Cherry

1

8        (V, s, u, sm, bud, h, n)

Choke Cherry

3

8        (V, s, u, sm, lm, bud, h)

Mountain Ash

Alien

6.5     (M, w, s, sm, lm, I, bud)

Wafer Ash

7

5.5     (M, s, u, sm, b, bud)

White Oak

5

10      (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud, h, n)

Swamp White Oak

6

9        (V, s, u, w, sm, b, bud, h)

Scarlet Oak

4

9        (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud, h)

Shingle Oak

7

9        (V, s, u, sm, b, w, bud, h)

Bur Oak

5

7        (V, s, u, w, sm, h)

Pin Oak

8

9        (V, s, u, w, sm, b, bud, h)

Red Oak

7

9        (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud, h)

Black Oak

6

9        (V, s, u, sm, b, I, bud, h)

Common Buckthorn

Alien

2        (L, s, h)

Glossy Buckthorn

Alien

2        (L, s, h)

Smooth Sumac

1

7.5     (M, s, u, b, lm, sm, bud, h)

Staghorn Sumac

1

7.5     (M, s, u, b, lm, sm, bud, h)

Poison Sumac

10

2.5     (M, s, sm)

Black Locust

Alien

1        (I)

Peach-leaved willow

5

9        (O, s, u, w, b, sm I, h, n)

Sandbar Willow

1

6.5     (M, u, b, sm, I, h, n)

Black Willow

4

8        (O, s, u, w, sm, I, h, n)

Sassafras

3

3.5     (M, I, h, n)

Elderberry

1

4.5     (M, s, I, bud, h)

Basswood

5

2        (L, sm, I)

Canadian Hemlock

10

3.5     (M, s, sm, I)

American Elm

3

6.5     (M, s, u, w, sm, bud, I)

Siberian Elm

Alien

4.5     (M, s, w, sm, bud)

Slippery Elm

4

4.5     (M, w, s, sm, bud)

Rock Elm

10

4.5     (M, w, s, sm, bud)

Sweet Viburnum

5

5        (O, s, u, sm, I)

Maple-leaved Viburnum  (native)

9

4        (O, s, sm, b)

Arrowwood Viburnum

Alien

4.5     (M, s, sm, b, h)

Highbush Cranberry  (native)

10

3        (S, B, SM)

Nannyberry

5

3        (S, B, SM)

Black Haw

5

8        (O, s, u, sm, b, I, bud, h)

Fox Grape

9

6        (O, s, u, sm, lm, I)

Prickly Ash

3

5        (O, s, u, sm, I)

V: Very high wildlife values overall (+2 on Wildlife Index scale)

O: High wildlife values overall (+1 on Wildlife Index scale)      

L:  Low wildlife value overall (0 points on Wildlife Index scale) 

s: songbird food source, usually fruits and seeds                                                                    

u: upland game bird food source (pheasants, wild turkeys and bobwhite quail)

sm: small mammal food source (rodents)  (These mammals can serve as food for larger carnivores.)

lm: large mammal food source (raccoons, opossums, skunk, foxes, and coyotes)

b: hooved browser food source (In our area this means white-tailed deer.)

w: waterfowl (especially in bottomland forests)

I: Insects feed on this plant extensively.  These will provide food for insectivorous birds.

bud: These buds are an important winter food for wildlife

h: These trees tend to provide nesting holes and cover for wildlife shelter.

n: Good nesting and shelter sites in these trees and bushes.

 

The obvious result here is that any new or restored habitat can help both plants and animals by promoting the following tree species: Oaks, Pines, Red Mulberry, Dogwoods, Birches, and Red Maples.  Do not plant alien species!  There are plenty of good native choices for each habitat type.

 

This index ranks trees and shrubs from 0 to 10. Zero is essentially worthless as wildlife food and shelter.  Ten is excellent. 

 

References:

Swink, F., & G. Wilhelm. 1994.  Plants of the Chicago Region, Indiana Academy of Science Press.

Martin, A.c, H. S. Zim, & A. L. Nelson. 1951. American Wildlife and Plants: A Guide to Wildlife Food Habits. Dover Press, N.Y.

Payne, N. F., & F. C. Bryant. 1998. Wildlife Habitat Management of Forestlands, Rangelands, and Farmlands. Krieger Press, FL

 

Comments & Suggestions on this handout should be sent to:  Randy Schietzelt, MS, Harper College, 1200 W. Algonquin Rd., Palatine, IL 60067, or emailed to rschietz@harpercollege.edu

"Environmental Awarness Through Birding"

McHenry County Audubon is a chapter of the Illinois Audubon Society. www.illinoisaudubon.org